Colony Counting: Method, Tips & Manual vs Automated

Colony counting is a key technique used in microbiology, offering critical insights into microbial populations in various scientific and industrial fields. This method allows researchers and professionals to estimate the number of microbes in a sample. It is the easiest and most common way to estimate the number of cells in a sample.

Manual colony counting can be tedious and choosing the right colony counter overwhelming. This means it is important for you to understand the benefits and limitations of both automatic and manual colony counters.

What is Colony Counting?

---

Colony counting is when the researcher estimates the number of microbes within the sample by counting the colonies that form on an agar plate. Each colony originates from a single viable microorganism. Colony counting is, therefore, a valuable method for assessing the presence, absence, or concentration of microbes in a sample. It provides insights into microbial growth patterns, antibiotic resistance, sensitivity to disinfectants, and genetic mutations. Additionally, colony counting is used to evaluate the effectiveness of treatments like fermentation, pasteurization, sterilization, or filtration. Regular microbial counts, expressed as colony forming units (CFU) per millilitre or gram, are an essential part of routine procedures.

Colony Forming Unit

A Colony Forming Unit is a measurement which estimates the number of viable microbial cells in a sample. It is based on the assumption that each viable microbe can reproduce and form colonies through binary fission under controlled conditions. The CFU per millilitre or gram is calculated based on the dilution factor and colony count.

Colony Counting Method

---

The colony counting process involves several steps:

1. Sample collection and dilution: Collect samples in aseptic conditions to avoid unwanted contamination. You may need to dilute the sample to ensure colony numbers remain countable. The sample dilution formula is:

 

2. Plating: Spread samples evenly on the agar plate using techniques such as the spread plate or pour plate method, carried out in the laminar flow hood.
3. Incubation: Incubate plates under specific conditions, such as temperature, based on the target microorganisms’ growth needs.
4. Counting: After incubations, count colonies using a manual or automatic colony counter.

Manual vs Automatic Colony Counters

---

Many microbiologists count colonies manually, which can be slow and time consuming. Additionally, some colonies may be too small to see clearly or may blend with color of the culture's medium. To address these challenges, an automated colony counter offers a sustainable and efficient solution. These instruments automate the counting process, ensuring fast and more accurate results, maintaining the integrity of biological procedures. Compared to counting colonies by hand, using a colony counter has several benefits:

• Accurate results: Colony counters use special software and imaging techniques to avoid mistakes that can occur with manual counting.
• Consistent and fair: No matter who uses the machine, it gives the same results every time.
• Extra information: Many colony counters can measure things like the size and shape of colonies. This extra data can be useful for research or checking the quality of products.

A colony counter is designed to help microbiologists count individual colonies, particularly bacteria and fungi, on solid agar plates. Both manual and automatic colony counters have their benefits, but the automatic counters offer significant advantages.

	Manual Colony Counter	Automatic Colony Counter
Cost	Low	Higher initial investment
Ease of use	Simple	Requires minimal training
Accuracy	Moderate; prone to errors	High; advanced image processing ensures precision
Throughput	Low; time consuming	High; rapid and efficient
Applications	Basic microbiology	Research, diagnostics, QC
Data management	None	Extensive storage and analysis capabilities

Manual Colony Counter

---

Manual colony counters include the following components:

• Illuminated base: The base of the counter is equipped with a bright, evenly lit surface that highlights the colonies on the petri dish.
• Pressure-sensitive surface: Many manual counters have a pressure-sensitive pad that registers and electronically counts each mark made by the researcher.
• Felt-tip pen: A specialized marking pen is used to manually highlight colonies on the petri dish. Each pen mark counts as one colony.
• Magnification lens: Some models include a built-in magnifying glass to help researchers in identifying smaller colonies.
• Digital display: Advanced manual counters may have a digital display that shows the total of counted colonies.

Principle of Operation

Begin by placing the petri dish on an illuminated pad designed to improve visibility. With a felt-tip pen, mark each colony directly on the dish. This triggers an electronic count, ensuring accurate tracking of the colonies. In some advanced models, magnification is included to assist in identifying small or densely packed colonies. This improves precision and reduces the likelihood of missed or overcounted colonies.

Advantages of Manual Colony Counters

Manual colony counters offer several advantages, particularly in settings that require flexibility and human expertise:

• These devices allow researchers to directly observe and mark colonies. This allows them to recognize overlapping colonies that automated counters might miss.
• Using magnification can help in detecting small areas of colonies.
• Manual counters are cost-effective, making them accessible for smaller laboratories or institutions.
• Their straightforward design means that they are easy to use and maintain. They do not depend on complex software, reducing the risk of technical issues.

Limitations of Manual Colony Counters

While manual colony counters are useful tools, they come with several limitations:

• The process of manually marking colonies can be time consuming and labor intensive.
• They have a higher risk of human error.
• Manual counters cannot provide advanced automated data analysis, such as detailed characterization of colonies by size or shape.
• Manual counting is not efficient for handling large sample volumes, making it less suitable for high-throughput laboratories.

Automatic Colony Counter

---

Automatic colony counters employ advanced imaging and software to streamline the counting process. Key components include:

• Petri dish platform: Holds and adjusts the position of the petri dish.
• Light source: Enhances contrast for better visibility using transmission, dark-field, or reflection methods.
• Camera: Captures high-resolution images of the colonies.
• Image processing software: Analyses the number of colonies and parameters like size, density, and morphology.
• Database: Stores and exports data for further analysis or reporting.

Principle of Operation

The light source illuminates the petri dish, which makes the colonies clearly visible for imaging. A high-resolution camera captures a detailed image of the dish. This image is then digitized and used as the basis for advanced computational analysis. Specialized algorithms process the image through several stages:

1. Grayscale conversion simplifies the image by removing color information.
2. Thresholding isolates the colonies by setting intensity levels to recognize them from the background.
3. Segmentation identifies individual colonies for further analysis.
4. The colonies are counted and characterized based on size, shape, and other parameters.

This automated system delivers results almost instantaneously, displaying them or exporting the data for further use in research or reporting.

Advantages of Automatic Colony Counters

Automatic colony counters provide numerous advantages, particularly in enhancing efficiency, accuracy, and scalability in microbiological analysis. These include:

• Reducing the time and labor required for counting colonies, making them ideal for high-throughput laboratories.
• Eliminating the inconsistencies by using algorithms to accurately identify, count, and analyze colonies, even in dense or overlapping samples.
• Providing detailed data on colony characteristics, such as size, shape, and color, which can be valuable for research.
• The results are generated and displayed within seconds.

Limitations of Automatic Colony Counters

While automatic colony counters are efficient and precise, they have limitations:

• Expensive; requiring significant investment and maintenance, which may be inaccessible to smaller labs.
• Their accuracy depends on image quality, and they can struggle with overlapping or irregular colonies that need human judgment.
• Rely on complex software, requiring trained operators and being prone to technical malfunctions.

Learn More

---

---

References

---

1. R. S. Khandpur Colony Counter, Automated Wiley online Library, Chapter 95, 2019
2. W.B. Chen & C. ZhangAn automated bacterial colony counting and classification system Springer Nature, vol. 11, pp. 349-268, 2009
3. E. Heuser, K. Becker & E.A. IdelevichEvaluation of an automated system for the counting of microbial colonies Microbiology Spectrum, vol. 11, 2023